This article will summarize kelsensopure theory of law, comment on his view of customary court. Legal positivism legal positivism is a theory about the nature of law, commonly thought to be characterized by two major tenets. This essay first sets out the epistemological basis of the pure theory in cognition of the law, that is, on how exactly law is perceived and recognized. Natural law, hans kelsen, thomas aquinas, aristotle. Basic norm or the grundnorm is a concept created by hans kelsen, a jurist and legal philosopher. Legality and legitimacy michel troper hans kelsens theory has, regretfully, been neglected in north america, except by a few legal philosophers.
For him, the legal science is an autonomous science, which must operate with its own methods and with absolute fidelity to their prisms of observation. Hans kelsen vienna school of jurisprudence positive law. Kelsen is most famous for his studies on law and especially for his idea known as the pure theory of the law. Hans kelsens argument from relativism this paper examines the conceptual relationship between legal positivism and human rights. This edited collection commences with a comprehensive introduction which establishes the character of kelsens critical engagement as a general critique of natural law combined. Hans kelsen retains the imperativalists monism but abandons their reductivism. Hans kelsen was an austrian lawyer and philosopher. Dec 08, 2014 hans kelsen was an austrian legal theorist, who worked in germany until the rise of the nazi party, and then in the usa. He published the first edition of the pure theory of law in 1934, and a second, expanded edition which i read in 1960. This collection of new essays takes kelsens pure theory of law as a stimulus, aiming to move forward the debate on several central issues in contemporary jurisprudence.
Focusing on the theoretical foundations of kelsen s legal positivism and weber s sociology of law, and guided by the conceptual frame of the juridicopolitical, the contributors to this. Although he was not of angloamerican birth, the idea of purity of his account of law, his views on legal structure and on the general form that all laws took, and his theory of legal validity, have contributed much to the theories of legal positivism. Indeed, hans kelsen remains an essential point of reference in the world of legal thought. First, in section 2, the author offers a view regarding the nature of law and legal normativity focusing on kelsen s work at least one reasonable reading of it. But despite kelsen s prominence as a legal theorist, his political theory has been mostly overlooked. Kelsen began his long career as a legal theorist at the beginning of the 20th century. Pdf kelsens pure theory of law naveed hussain academia.
The theory is pure because it separates jurisprudence from other disciplines like ethics, politics. Possibly the most influential jurisprudent of the twentieth century, hans kelsen 18811973 was legal adviser to austrias last emperor and its first republican government, the founder and permanent advisor of the supreme constitutional court of austria, and the author of austrias constitution, which was enacted in 1920, abolished during the. In the following two sections, i attempt to give a general account of the legal theories of gustav radbruch and hans kelsen, with an emphasis on the question of legal validity. This book argues that kelsen s pure theory of law needs to be read in the context of kelsen s political theory. This classic work by the important austrian jurist is the fullest exposition of his enormously influential pure theory of law, which includes a theory of the state. Hart 190792 and joseph raz, among whom there are clear lines of influence, but also important contrasts. Hans kelsen on international law francois rigaux abstract kelsens monistic theory of law, according to which international and municipal law have the same subjectmatter, paved the way for the dominant contemporary doctrine. There are familiar questions connected with explaining legal.
Once we reject the denial of the legal quality of international law, we have to acknowledge, in kelsens view, that all national legal systems are subordinate parts of one global legal system and to support the further institutionalization of that legal system. Kelsen lives european journal of international law. Summary of hans kelsens pure theory of law hugh mccarthy. But despite kelsens prominence as a legal theorist, his political theory has been mostly overlooked. General theory of law and state, by hans kelsen, translated. I have in mind is not, however, hans kelsen or his theory in particular. He gained a worldwide reputation for his pure theory of law reine rechtslehrea. The traditional legal philosophies at the time, were, kelsen claimed, hopelessly contaminated with.
Hans kelsen was an austrian legal theorist, who worked in germany until the rise of the nazi party, and then in the usa. October 11, 1881 april 19, 1973 was an austrian jurist, legal philosopher and political philosopher. The great trend of analytical jurisprudence, going back to bentham and austin, has reached in kelsen s work a. This edited collection commences with a comprehensive introduction which establishes the character of kelsen s critical engagement as a general critique of natural law combined. Hans kelsen 1881 1973, the main name of legal positivism.
Hans kelsen s farewell address as an active member of the university of california faculty is a fitting introductory chapter to the collection of fifteen essays which comprise his latest book. Kelsen s pure theory of law is, no doubt, the outstanding achievement of our time in legal theory. This edited collection commences with a comprehensive introduction which establishes the character of kelsens critical. Kelsens theory of grundnorm india law legal database. The idea of a pure theory of law was propounded by the formidable austrian jurist and philosopher hans kelsen 18811973 see the bibliographical note. Hans kelsen and the natural law tradition provides the first sustained examination of hans kelsen s critical engagement, itself founded upon a distinctive theory of legal positivism, with the natural law tradition. Law, critical legal positivism constitutional law and international law, philosophy of law issues of justice, natural law, sociology causality and retribution, political theory democracy, socialism, bolshevism and critiques of ideology. John austin, hans kelsen, and herbert hartdo not converge on many. Hans kelsen and the bindingness of supranational legal norms. Kelsen was born in prague in 1881, but his jewish, germanspeaking family soon moved to vienna, austria, where he completed his education through his doctorate in law. Legal positivism is the thesis that the existence and content of law. Translation from the second german edition by max knight.
The pure theory of law stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Legal positivism oxford academic journals oxford university. Hans kelsen s argument from relativism this paper examines the conceptual relationship between legal positivism and human rights. Hans kelsen and the bindingness of supranational legal. Pdf legal positivism, conventionalism, and the normativity of law. Hans kelsens pure theory of law in the land of the legal realists 355 writings tend to be political theorists, and to this day, no u. This article focuses on issues relating to legal normativity, emphasizing the way these matters have been elaborated in the works of kelsen and hart and later commentators on their theories. Kelsens legal cosmopolitanism argues that there is no good jurisprudential reason to deny that international law is real law. Kelsen s legal cosmopolitanism argues that there is no good jurisprudential reason to deny that international law is real law.
His work has been studied wherever legal theory is studied. The theory is pure because it separates jurisprudence. International legal realism as a theory of uncertainty, 58 harv. The precise question before the supreme court was whether the high courts had jurisdiction under article 98 of the constitution of. It offers the first comprehensive interpretation of the pure theory that makes systematic use. A philosophical reading of legal positivism tel archives ouvertes. Recently there have been two attempts to understand democracy as a source for the normativity that the pure theory assigns to law. The main objective of hans kelsen in the pure theory of law is to. Hans kelsen was a european legal philosopher and teacher who emigrated to the united states in 1940 after leaving nazi germany. Kelsen was born in prague, czechoslovakia, on october 11, 1881. In his essay the naturallaw doctrine before the tribunal of science, published originally in 1949. His major works on legal positivism were the general theory of law and state and the pure theory of law. Pdf the theory of legal positivism has been much discussed over the. The austrian philosopher and jurist named han kelsen proposed the pure theory of law.
Pdf hans kelsen pure theory of law majd rashyd academia. Legal positivism is a general and descriptive theory of law of the type advanced by scholars like john austin, 4 hans kelsen, 5 alf ross, 6 h. Paulson legal positivism in the jurisprudential tradition of the european continent is characterised by what might be called the facticity thesis. A landmark in the development of modern jurisprudence, the. As part of the legal positivist separation of law and morality that he advocated, a hart. Hans kelsen was a legal theorist, best known for his writings on international law and for his creation of the concept of a constitutional court. It also has an extensive appendix that discusses the pure theory in comparison with the law of nature, positivism, historical natural law, metaphysical dualism and scientificcritical philosophy. Legal positivism stanford encyclopedia of philosophy.
Hans kelsen and the natural law tradition provides the first sustained examination of hans kelsens critical engagement, itself founded upon a distinctive theory of legal positivism, with the natural law tradition. Hart, and many other legal theorists of the past century1 is the idea that law is a normative system, and that any theory about the nature of law must focus on its normativity. Kelsens pure theory of law is, no doubt, the outstanding achievement of our time in legal theory. Hans kelsens pure theory of law by tim murphy ssrn. Legal positivism is the legal philosophy which argues that any and all laws are nothing more and nothing less than simply the expression of the will of whatever authority created them. Hans kelsens pure theory of law and its doctrine of the grund norm has achieved a. The most important architects of contemporary legal positivism are the austrian jurist hans kelsen 18811973 and the two dominating figures in the analytic philosophy of law, h. Kelsen was a theorist and philosopher who renewed legal positivism and found new answers to the fundamental question of how law is to be constructed and understood. The great trend of analytical jurisprudence, going.
Hans kelsens theory has, regretfully, been neglected in north america, except by a few legal philosophers. Found at these bookshops searching please wait originally published in hebrew in by manges press. Forty years after his death, hans kelsen 18811973 remains one of the most discussed and influential legal philosophers of our time. Hans kelsen is considered to be one of the founding fathers of modern legal philosophy. Hans kelsens pure theory of law is a positivist theory that has been enormously influential in the world of jurisprudence. International journal of law and legal jurisprudence studies, volume 1, issue 6 6 john austins analytical jurisprudence and legal positivism john austin 17901859 was a prominent british legal philosopher who takes the credit for formulating the first systematic alternative to both natural law theories of law and utilitarian. While kelsen is of course defending the separation principle, his position represents a wholesale rejection of naturalism.
Hans kelsens farewell address as an active member of the university of california faculty is a fitting introductory chapter to the collection of fifteen essays which comprise his latest book. Vol 4 the western australian jurist 285 hans kelsens theory and the key to his normativist dimension kendra frew i introduction writers have both praised and criticised hans kelsens work, however all would agree that he is a theorist to be reckoned with. Apr 24, 2019 found at these bookshops searching please wait originally published in hebrew in by manges press. Jurisprudence pure theory of law by hans kelsen part 2. Kelsen, hart, and legal normativity openedition journals. According to kelsen law is a normative science jurisprudence is the knowledge of norms. One of the main reasons for the neglect of kelsens political theory is that it is considered to be at odds with his legal theory, and. A norm of law is simply a preposition in hypothetical from. Request pdf reconciling legal positivism and human rights. Hart, and many other legal theorists for legal normative systems kelsen called the basic norm grundnorm oing ssay his on orget utline elsen heory irst articularly he ature. Hans kelsen was one of the most significant legal scholars of the 20th century. Hans kelsen 18811973 biographical note and bibliography.
Henry cohen hans kelsen 18811973 was a leading germanamerican legal positivist. Introduction the socalled naturallaw doctrine is a constant target of criticism by hans kelsen. Kelsen used this word to denote the basic norm, order, or rule that forms an underlying basis for a legal system. Overview hans kelsen was an austrian legal theorist, who worked in germany until the rise of the nazi party, and then in the usa. Analytical jurisprudence deontological ethics interpretivism legalism legal moralism legal positivism legal realism libertarian theories of law natural law paternalism utilitarianism virtue. Thus, no laws can be regarded as expressions of higher morality or higher principles to which people can appeal when they disagree with the laws. According to kelsons pure theory of law, it must be free from ethics, morality, politics sociology, history etc it must be pure. He was the author of the 1920 austrian constitution, which to a very large degree is still valid today.
244 295 1301 1196 653 1091 757 937 303 1372 402 453 107 238 45 576 727 1274 350 1386 1119 524 883 114 1108 600 241 1301 1258 1310 1459 97 675 1220 55